ANTRLRequest a briefing

Early-warning signals, explained

In many complex systems, recovery from small disturbances slows before a larger shift. That slowing can show up as rising autocorrelation and variance. Here is what the idea can, and cannot, tell you about one person.

Article · Reviewed 3 November 2026

Critical slowing down

As a system approaches a tipping point, it takes longer to bounce back from small knocks. Researchers call this critical slowing down, and it has been studied in ecosystems, climate and other systems (Scheffer et al., 2009). Its traces are rising lag-1 autocorrelation and rising variance.

How it is measured

Standard methods detrend a series, compute the indicators in a rolling window, test their trend, and compare the result with surrogate data (Dakos et al., 2012). The State-Change Signal follows that procedure.

What group studies found

At the group level, researchers found signs of critical slowing down in mood measures before changes in depression (van de Leemput et al., 2014). ATS-1 tags this Model, with mixed evidence.

Why one person's signals are uncertain

A 2024 review found that, at the level of one person, the signals appeared before fewer than half of changes, and in about 25% of people whose state did not change (Helmich et al., 2024). That is why ATS-1 reports a graded statement, never an alert, and why every output carries the disclosure. The false-alarm calculator shows what it means for a group.

A research estimate

ATS-1 is for research and general wellness only. It does not diagnose, treat, prevent or predict any disease, including any mental health condition. The State-Change Signal is a research estimate of change in self-reported wellbeing patterns, not a prediction of any health condition.

Questions

Can early-warning signals tell me a change is coming?

Not reliably for one person. They are research estimates with substantial uncertainty.

Sources

  1. Scheffer et al., 2009
  2. Dakos et al., 2012
  3. van de Leemput et al., 2014
  4. Helmich et al., 2024

Keep reading

Take the next step.

What early-warning signals are, why recovery slows near a shift, what group studies found, and why one person's signals are uncertain.